Lawful Processing & Individual Rights, 30 min read

Legal bases and valid consent

In this lesson you will:

  • Explain why every processing purpose needs a legal basis
  • Choose an appropriate legal basis from common options
  • Test whether consent is valid and manageable
  • Run a simple legitimate-interests balancing test

The first privacy principle says processing must be lawful. In practice that means each purpose needs a recognised legal reason before any data is collected. Pick the wrong basis and everything built on it is unlawful, even if the data is perfectly secure.

1. One purpose, one basis

Legal bases attach to purposes, not to datasets. An online shop processes the same customer record to deliver orders, to keep tax records, to detect fraud and to send promotions. Each purpose may rest on a different basis, and each choice changes what rights the customer has and what the shop must do.

Decide the basis before processing starts, record it, and tell people in the notice. Switching bases later, for example falling back on "legitimate interests" when consent is withdrawn, is usually unfair and often unlawful.

GDPR lists six bases, and most laws use a similar set, sometimes under different names.

Basis Use it when Example
Consent The person has a genuine choice and you can honour a "no" Marketing emails, optional cookies
Contract Processing is necessary to deliver what the person asked for Shipping address to deliver an order
Legal obligation A law requires it Keeping invoices for tax law, KYC checks
Vital interests Someone's life is at risk and they cannot consent Sharing allergy data with paramedics
Public task Exercising official authority or a task in the public interest A city council running housing services
Legitimate interests A real business interest that is not overridden by the person's rights Fraud prevention, network security, basic analytics

Laws vary. India's DPDP Act relies mainly on consent, but allows "certain legitimate uses" without consent, such as data a person voluntarily provides for a specific purpose, state benefits and services, legal obligations, medical emergencies, disasters and some employment purposes. It has no general "legitimate interests" basis. Brazil's LGPD has ten bases, including credit protection. Most US state laws do not require a basis for ordinary processing; they rely on notice and opt-out rights, but require opt-in consent for sensitive data in several states.

Consent is only valid if it meets every condition below. Miss one and it is not consent.

  • Freely given: a genuine choice, no detriment for saying no, not bundled with unrelated terms, and not demanded where there is a power imbalance (employers, public authorities).
  • Specific: separate consent for separate purposes.
  • Informed: the person knows who you are, what data, which purposes, and that they can withdraw.
  • Unambiguous: a clear affirmative action, such as ticking an empty box or pressing "Agree". Silence, pre-ticked boxes and inactivity are not consent.
  • Withdrawable: as easy to withdraw as to give, and processing stops when consent is withdrawn.
  • Recorded: you can prove who consented, when, to what wording, and how.

DPDP adds that consent must be preceded by an itemised notice, be limited to the data necessary for the purpose, and be available in English or any of the 22 languages in the Eighth Schedule of India's Constitution. It also introduces consent managers: registered intermediaries that let people give, review and withdraw consent across many organisations from one place.

🔐 Privacy lens

Consent is fragile. People can withdraw it at any time, so never choose consent for processing you cannot stop, such as records you must keep by law. Use the basis that matches reality.

4. The legitimate-interests balancing test

Where a law allows legitimate interests, you must show three things and record them in a legitimate interests assessment (LIA):

  1. Purpose test: is there a real, lawful interest (yours or a third party's)?
  2. Necessity test: is the processing necessary for it, or is there a less intrusive way?
  3. Balancing test: do the person's interests, rights and reasonable expectations override yours? Consider the type of data, the relationship, the impact, safeguards and whether children are involved.
Three gates of the legitimate interests test: purpose, necessity and balancing, with questions for each and safeguards that tip the balance.
Figure 2.3 The three-part legitimate-interests test. Fail any gate and you need another basis.

Worked example — choosing bases for an online pharmacy

Purpose Basis chosen Reasoning
Fulfil prescription orders Contract (plus the health-data condition for providing care) Needed to deliver what the customer ordered
Keep dispensing records for the period the law sets Legal obligation Pharmacy regulations require it; consent would be misleading
Detect fraudulent prescriptions Legitimate interests (LIA recorded) or legal obligation where rules require checks Expected, necessary and protective of patients
Send health-product promotions Consent, separate opt-in, unticked box Optional; health context makes it sensitive
Share data with a research partner Consent, or anonymise first Not expected by customers; high sensitivity

Under DPDP the same pharmacy would rely on consent for most purposes, with "legitimate uses" covering legal obligations and medical emergencies.

Key takeaways

  • Every purpose needs a legal basis, chosen and recorded before processing begins.
  • Common bases: consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, legitimate interests; laws differ in which they allow.
  • Valid consent is freely given, specific, informed, unambiguous, withdrawable and recorded.
  • Legitimate interests requires a documented purpose, necessity and balancing test.
  • DPDP relies on consent plus defined legitimate uses, with consent managers as a new mechanism.

Self-check

  1. Why is consent a poor basis for processing an employer must do by law?
  2. Name three things that make consent invalid.
  3. What are the three parts of a legitimate-interests assessment?