STRIDE and Other Methodologies, 10 min read

Ready reckoner

STRIDE

Letter Threat Violates Example Typical controls
S Spoofing Authentication Credential stuffing; forged webhook MFA, mTLS, signed webhooks
T Tampering Integrity Change amount/beneficiary; edit file Server-side authZ on writes, signing, idempotency
R Repudiation Non-repudiation "I never issued that refund" Per-person IDs, append-only off-host logs
I Information disclosure Confidentiality IDOR read; leaky errors; open backups AuthZ on reads, encryption, minimisation
D Denial of service Availability Sale-time flood; denial of wallet Rate limits, quotas, timeouts, cost caps
E Elevation of privilege Authorisation UI-only admin check Server-side checks, least privilege, maker-checker

STRIDE-per-element

Element S T R I D E
External entity ✓ ✓
Process ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Data store ✓ (logs) ✓ ✓
Data flow ✓ ✓ ✓

Per-interaction: for each boundary-crossing flow, consider sender + flow + receiver together. Fewer duplicates.

Mistakes: stopping at the letter · checklist mindset · classification debates · analysing inside external entities · forgetting people · ignoring existing controls.

Rating

  • Likelihood × impact (1–5 each) with a written, business-specific scale. Kestrel: sum 8–10 fix now; 6–7 plan or accept; 2–5 track.
  • DREAD: subjective; discoverability rewards obscurity; deprecated by Microsoft.
  • CVSS v4.0: confirmed vulnerabilities, not design threats; severity ≠ risk.
  • OWASP Risk Rating: factor-based middle ground. FAIR: money ranges for board cases. Bug bars: predefined severities.

Threat libraries

CAPEC (attack patterns) · ATT&CK (real intrusion TTPs) · CWE (weaknesses, e.g. CWE-639 IDOR) · OWASP Top 10 lists.

Other methods

Method Centred on Use when
PASTA (7 stages) Business risk Critical systems; regulator/board audience
LINDDUN Privacy Personal data; DPIA input
Attack trees One attacker goal Deep dive; OR vs AND; cheapest path
OCTAVE / Allegro Organisation Enterprise risk assessment
Trike Allowed CRUD actions Requirements-driven, rigorous
VAST Scale + automation Many teams; app vs operational models
hTMM / persona non grata Attacker personas Bring motivation and intel in
Kill chain / ATT&CK Intrusion stages Defence in depth, detection points
Elevation of Privilege cards STRIDE as a game Teaching, engaging teams

PASTA stages: objectives → technical scope → decomposition → threat analysis → vulnerability analysis → attack modelling → risk & impact. LINDDUN: Linking · Identifying · Non-repudiation · Detecting · Data disclosure · Unawareness · Non-compliance. Non-repudiation is a goal in STRIDE but a privacy threat in LINDDUN.