Cloud computing means personal data rarely stays in one country. But most privacy laws restrict sending it abroad unless the destination offers enough protection. Here are the main mechanisms and the different approaches across jurisdictions.
Why transfers are restricted
The concern is simple: if data leaves a country with strong privacy law for one with weak law, individuals lose their protection. Transfer rules try to make protection "travel with the data". Some countries also restrict transfers for sovereignty or security reasons, which is a different goal: keeping certain data within reach of local authorities.
The main mechanisms
Adequacy
A regulator or government declares that a destination country's law gives comparable protection. Transfers to that country then need no extra steps. The EU has adequacy decisions for a set list of countries, including Japan, South Korea and the UK, and the EU–US Data Privacy Framework for certified US companies.
Contractual clauses
The exporter and importer sign standard clauses committing the importer to protect the data. The EU's Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) are the best known. ASEAN has published Model Contractual Clauses for intra-ASEAN transfers. Since the EU's Schrems II judgment, exporters are expected to assess whether the destination's laws, especially government access, undermine the clauses. This is a transfer impact assessment.
Binding corporate rules
Multinational groups can adopt BCRs: internal rules approved by regulators that allow transfers within the group. They take a long time to approve but suit large groups with many internal flows.
Certifications
Schemes such as the Global Cross-Border Privacy Rules (CBPR) system, which grew out of APEC, certify that a company's practices meet a common standard. Singapore, Japan, Korea and others recognise CBPR in their transfer rules.
Consent and specific exceptions
Most laws allow transfers with the individual's explicit consent, or where necessary to perform a contract with them, or for legal claims. These suit occasional transfers, not routine bulk flows.
How Asian laws approach it
| Jurisdiction | Approach |
|---|---|
| India (DPDP Act) | Negative list: transfers are allowed except to countries the government restricts. Sector rules (for example RBI payment data) can still require localisation, and Significant Data Fiduciaries may have to keep specified data in India. |
| Singapore (PDPA) | The exporter must ensure the recipient is bound to comparable protection, for example through contracts, BCRs or CBPR certification. |
| Malaysia (PDPA) | Allowed where the destination has substantially similar law or adequate protection, or another condition applies. The old whitelist approach was replaced in the 2024 amendments. |
| Vietnam (PDPL) | A transfer impact assessment dossier must be prepared and filed with the Ministry of Public Security. |
| Indonesia (PDP Law) | A hierarchy: an adequate destination, then appropriate safeguards, then consent. |
| Thailand (PDPA) | Adequate destination, or appropriate safeguards such as BCRs or contracts, or listed exceptions. |
| China (PIPL) | Security assessment, certification or standard contract depending on volume and type, with some exemptions introduced in 2024. |
Practical steps
- Map your transfers. For each system and vendor: what data, from which country, to which country, including support access from abroad, which counts as a transfer under most laws.
- Pick a mechanism per route and record it.
- Do transfer impact assessments where required, focusing on government access and on the importer's security.
- Put clauses in vendor contracts and flow them down to sub-processors.
- Minimise. Pseudonymise or encrypt with keys held in the exporting country where possible, so the importer sees less.
- Watch for change. Adequacy decisions get challenged, and lists of restricted countries can be notified at short notice.
Learn more
Our free Data Protection & Privacy Fundamentals course explains transfers, vendor management and privacy programmes in a law-neutral way. Compare regional laws in Asia-Pacific privacy laws compared.
Written and reviewed by the DigiTrust Asia editorial team. How we research, review and correct articles.
General information, not legal advice. Laws and official guidance change; check the current text before acting.
Learn privacy properly
Data Protection & Privacy Fundamentals is a free, law-neutral course with a final exam and certificate.
Create a free account